Milburn Reform Promises £13.8 Billion in Savings, but Only £200 Million a Year by 2036
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Rencana reformasi tunjangan pemuda Alan Milburn diproyeksikan hanya menghemat £200 juta per tahun pada 2036, jauh dari klaim awal £13,8 miliar.
- Jumlah pemuda Inggris penerima tunjangan kesehatan melonjak dua kali lipat sejak 2020, memicu kekhawatiran beban fiskal jangka panjang.
- Pemerintah Inggris diminta menyeimbangkan insentif kerja dan disiplin fiskal, sementara pengamat menilai target penghematan tidak realistis tanpa pertumbuhan ekonomi kuat.

The reform of the benefits system for England's younger generation championed by Alan Milburn has come under scrutiny after official projections showed net savings of just £200 million (around Rp4 trillion) a year by 2036—a figure far short of the claimed potential savings of £13.8 billion over a decade. The public is now questioning the effectiveness of a plan billed as a breakthrough in social policy.
Milburn, a former minister tasked with designing a strategy to reduce the number of young people not in employment, education, or training (Neets), proposed a combination of two major policies: injecting an additional £5.8 billion a year into wage subsidies and mental health support, and overhauling the benefits scheme so that young people no longer access the same health and disability support as older age groups. He envisions a reduction in welfare spending of £3.6 billion a year by 2036, which he claims would save a total of £13.8 billion from the state budget over ten years.
However, calculations by BBC Verify show that after accounting for an additional £2.4 billion in tax revenue from a growing number of workers, annual net savings reach only £200 million—equivalent to 1% of current total benefits spending. This figure does not even account for inflation and economic dynamics that could erode its real value. Several economists also consider the target too ambitious given the complexity of the problem.
Nevertheless, Milburn stressed that his diagnosis applies to the whole of the UK, while asking the Scottish, Welsh, and Northern Irish governments to agree on "a set of shared core outcomes" because powers over education, skills, health, and local government have been devolved. He is optimistic that the reform will yield long-term results as more young people enter the labor market.
"We cannot rely on tightening benefits alone. There must be real investment in skills and mental health so that they can genuinely work," Milburn said in the report, as quoted.
Criticism has also emerged. Several researchers noted that welfare spending as a percentage of GDP rises only slightly from 11.1% this year to 11.3% in 2032—still below the 12% peak in 2013 after the global financial crisis. They argue that the narrative of "uncontrolled welfare spending" is not entirely accurate, so a reform too focused on savings risks ignoring the root problem: a lack of decent jobs and adequate mental health support.
For Indonesia, this dynamic is an important mirror. Social security and social assistance programs in the country face similar challenges: a growing number of working-age beneficiaries who are not absorbed by the labor market. If the UK—with its capable administrative system—struggles to achieve significant savings, Indonesia needs to learn that benefits reform must be accompanied by job creation and improved vocational education. Without that, fiscal targets will remain numbers on paper.
Looking ahead, the question is: will the UK government dare to take the unpopular step of cutting benefits for the younger generation, or will it instead choose a more expensive but sustainable path of social investment? What is clear is that the Milburn reform will be a test of the credibility of savings promises amid global fiscal pressure.



