The EU of 2026 Is Not the EU Britain Left: Burnham and the Illusion of 'Small Steps'
Baca dalam 60 detik
- KTT Inggris-UE di Brussels hanya menghasilkan kesepakatan terbatas: skema mobilitas pemuda, harga karbon lintas selat, dan pelonggaran perdagangan pangan.
- Uni Eropa pasca-Brexit telah berubah menjadi blok yang lebih proteksionis, terpusat, dan waspada terhadap komitmen Inggris yang dianggap tidak konsisten.
- Peluang politik bagi Burnham untuk mendekat sebenarnya menyempit menjelang pemilu Prancis, ketika isu Inggris berpotensi tersingkir dari agenda Brussels.

UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham calls a series of agreements with the European Union a “step” toward a closer relationship. In Brussels, however, the move is read as a cautious maneuver amid a European political landscape that has changed drastically since the 2016 Brexit referendum.
At the UK-EU summit on Friday (local time), what was actually discussed was not rejoining but technical cooperation: a youth mobility scheme, a cross-Channel carbon emissions price agreement, and easier food trade. The talks also touched on tuition fee reductions for EU students at UK universities—a request from Germany and several member states—in exchange for UK access to EU manufacturing schemes. Even in this limited area, several details remain unresolved.
Burnham acknowledges the step is part of a gradual approach. He does not promise a great leap, let alone rejoining the bloc anytime soon. Yet behind the rhetoric of “small steps” lies a fundamental question rarely discussed: is the European Union Burnham wants to approach still the same European Union Britain left a decade ago?
The answer: no. A series of global shocks has fundamentally changed Brussels. The Covid-19 pandemic opened Europe's eyes to its dependence on China for medical supplies. Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022 forced member states—especially Germany and Italy—to recognize their energy vulnerability. The war in Ukraine, Europe's largest conflict since World War II, pushed the EU to strengthen its defense industry and domestic industrial policy.
Donald Trump's two terms in the White House also left a bitter lesson: Europe can no longer rely entirely on the United States, whether in trade or security. Meanwhile, China's efforts to flood Europe with cheap cars and steel have made the EU increasingly protectionist. Brussels' conclusion: Europe must be more self-reliant, and if it still imports—fossil fuels, for example—its sources must be diversified.
This shift is not only about policy. According to Charles Grant, director of the Centre for European Reform, Britain has changed too. “The British are now less ‘British’ than they were,” he said. When the EU imposed anti-dumping steel tariffs on China, Britain followed with similar tariffs. Now, as the EU imposes high tariffs on Chinese electric cars, Britain is again considering a similar move. “Everyone is a bit more French now,” Grant said.
Another equally important change is the growing acceptance of the idea of centralized European power. The Covid-19 crisis pushed the EU to adopt joint borrowing—Brussels issued debt on behalf of member states, which then shared the benefits and risks. That historic step, especially for Germany, which was once allergic to the idea, is now being continued with discussions of joint borrowing for defense. Some EU officials even say this would not have been possible if a more sovereign Britain had remained a member.
Yet a wind of political change is blowing hard within the bloc. Nationalist and euroskeptic parties are gaining strength in large EU countries ahead of elections. In France, Marine Le Pen of the hard right leads the polls ahead of the spring presidential election. Nation-first parties in Italy, Spain, and Poland—as in France—promise to change the bloc from within.
If Le Pen becomes French president, Brussels will be dragged into an internal existential struggle: left against right, pro-European against euroskeptic, supporters of Ukraine against those who want to stop financial aid. In that situation, negotiations with Britain would likely drop in priority. British diplomats might find their calls go unanswered.
Georgina Wright, a senior adviser at the German Marshall Fund, argues that if Burnham is serious about moving closer to the EU, the time to act is now—before the French election. She sees an opportunity for Britain to be “creative” in its realignment proposals. “The prime minister should be on the ground in continental Europe more often, more visible, and speaking more positively about what can be done together,” Wright said.
Wright cites a National Centre for Social Research survey showing 42% of Britons prioritize closer relations with Europe, while only 9% prioritize relations with the US. Behind closed doors, however, EU countries still harbor doubts. The word “commitment” comes up repeatedly. They heard Conservative Party deputy chairman Alex Burghart vow to “tear up” UK-EU agreements if his party comes to power. “Britain first needs a national conversation. And a binding decision. They must know what they want and be consistent,” an EU official said.
That warning is exactly the same one Brussels delivered a decade ago, after Britain voted for Brexit without a clear political plan. Michel Barnier, the EU's chief Brexit negotiator, insisted Britain cannot pick all the benefits without the obligations. The single market is the bloc's crown jewel, and Brussels will not damage it with large exceptions that other non-EU countries would then demand.
Economist Heather Grabbe of Bruegel predicts an “inevitable mutual shift” between the two sides. “We face the same challenges: aging populations, wildfires and storms, the impact of climate change with our continent warming twice the global average. Russia attacks us all with hybrid warfare. Our view is the same: we are not pro-Trump, not pro-Putin. Working together makes sense,” she said.
Yet the remaining question is whether Brussels truly wants Britain back, or is instead avoiding new drama. An EU diplomat from a large country, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Britain needs Brussels more than the reverse. “Britain alone is a middle power among giants. With China on one side and the US on the other, Britain will be trampled if it stands alone. They must know that,” the diplomat said.
If Britain ever rejoins, it would not necessarily have to adopt the euro or the Schengen scheme right away. But until then, Britain remains outside the decision-making circle. Burnham may call it a “small step,” but in Brussels, that step only means something if accompanied by binding commitments. Without that, Britain will only repeat history: negotiating with a Europe that has changed, while domestic politics keeps pulling it back to the past.



