UK Energy Insulation Scheme Fails: 90% of Damaged Homes Still Unrepaired
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Dari 24.600 rumah terdampak isolasi eksterior cacat, baru 2.227 unit yang tuntas diperbaiki.
- Regulator Ofgem dan TrustMark saling lempar tanggung jawab soal pengawasan kualitas instalasi.
- Pemerintah menyiapkan Warm Homes Plan untuk merombak sistem dan mencegah terulangnya kegagalan.

Only about 9% of the 24,600 homes identified as having defective external wall insulation in the UK had completed repairs as of early this week. Energy Minister Martin McClusky disclosed the figure at a parliamentary committee meeting on Wednesday (5/3/2025), stating that the government's energy efficiency schemes—ECO4 and the Great British Insulation Scheme (GBIS)—had run without adequate oversight.
McClusky said he was surprised by the scale of the failure and promised affected households would not bear the cost of repairs. “There has clearly been a systemic failure. We are designing a new system,” he said when asked about his confidence in Ofgem, the energy regulator overseeing the schemes. He did not directly answer the question about his trust in the agency.
Official data shows that of the total 24,600 homes that received external wall insulation through the two schemes, only 2,227 units have been fully repaired. The government and its partners had actually known about the significant damage levels since an October 2024 audit, but repairs have been slow. Ofgem argues it has no mandate to assess installation quality—a task its spokesperson says belongs to the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ).
The case of Ken Palfrey, a 66-year-old retired builder from Birmingham, illustrates the tangled bureaucracy. Insulation installed in 2024 damaged window sills and triggered damp and mould. After inspection, the insulation was declared improperly installed and had to be removed immediately. “I've been going round in circles for two years, spending hundreds of hours writing emails and complaining,” he said. TrustMark only referred his case to the National Energy Foundation (NEF) this month.
“It's a nightmare. Every day, every time you look at that insulation, you worry,” Palfrey said.
Labour MP Bill Esterson, who chairs the Energy Security and Net Zero Committee, demanded assurances that victims “will be supported in a timely manner.” He highlighted Ofgem's failure to identify whether the work had been done to standard. An Ofgem spokesperson stressed that the agency is not responsible for guaranteeing installation quality, but has stepped beyond its core role to help affected households.
Meanwhile, Fuel Poverty Action argues the problem is broader than the government acknowledges. The group estimates up to 100,000 homes may be affected, including internal wall insulation which the government says is 29% defective but was not included in the Find and Fix process. “Ignoring other remediation steps is a shameful neglect,” said Jonathan Bean, the group's head of policy.
A DESNZ spokesperson said the department inherited the failed ECO4 scheme and has ended it. “No household should have to pay to fix this problem,” the spokesperson said, adding that the Warm Homes Plan will overhaul the consumer protection system.
For Indonesia, this case is an important mirror: subsidized energy efficiency programs—such as home retrofits or stove conversions—require strict quality oversight and clear accountability mechanisms. Without them, state budgets can be drained by repairs rather than emissions reductions. The question is whether the UK government will complete all repairs before ECO4 closes in December, or whether this scandal will become a legacy that continues to haunt the energy transition.



