MSCI Drops Strategy From Index, a Move That Could Disrupt Its Bitcoin Buying Engine
Baca dalam 60 detik
- MSCI memastikan Strategy keluar dari indeks global per 30 November, memicu penjualan paksa oleh dana pasif.
- Penurunan premi mNAV mendekati 1,08x membuat penerbitan saham baru kurang akretif untuk membiayai pembelian Bitcoin.
- Tekanan jual diperkirakan sekitar 13 juta saham atau setara 3,1% saham beredar, namun sebagian besar sudah tercermin di harga.

MSCI's decision to remove Strategy—the largest publicly traded Bitcoin holder—from its global equity indexes effective November 30 is a fresh blow to a business model that has relied on issuing shares to accumulate BTC. MSCI confirmed the news after a public consultation, marking the first time the index giant has applied the "non-operating" screen it adopted on October 15.
The move does not immediately delist Strategy's shares, nor does it force the company to sell its Bitcoin holdings of 850,364 BTC, worth about US$62.6 billion. But because many institutional funds are required to track index composition, the exclusion automatically triggers a wave of selling from mutual funds and ETFs that track MSCI indexes. At the same time, Tokyo-based Metaplanet was also removed from the MSCI Japan Small Cap Index under a similar policy.
Several analysts estimate selling pressure on MSTR—Strategy's ticker—at around 13 million shares, or about 3.1% of total shares outstanding. That figure is relatively small, below average daily trading volume, and equal to US$1.6 billion at Wednesday's prices. The estimate is in line with Strategy's own acknowledgment in its response to MSCI. However, JPMorgan in a November 2025 report projected potential outflows of up to US$2.8 billion, which could swell to US$8.8 billion if other index providers follow MSCI's lead. The discrepancy arises because JPMorgan's estimate was based on the initial proposal, not the final rule just approved.
More concerning, according to BloFin research, is the impact on Strategy's future pace of Bitcoin accumulation. The company has financed BTC purchases by issuing convertible bonds, preferred stock, and common stock through at-the-market programs. That strategy only works when the stock trades above its net asset value—or mNAV above 1x. With mNAV now near 1.08x, each new share issuance adds almost no value for existing shareholders and could even be dilutive if it falls below 1x.
Signs of a shift in capital priorities are already visible in Strategy's report for the week ended November 8. The company raised US$283.8 million from the sale of 2.05 million common shares, but only US$81.9 million was allocated to Bitcoin (1,036 BTC). Most of the funds—US$188.3 million—went to repurchasing STRC preferred stock, while US$13.6 million was added to cash. The same report showed cash reserves of US$4.77 billion as of November 8, with US$21.1 million drawn to pay preferred dividends, and no Bitcoin sales.
"With the NAV premium near 1.0, the stock offers lower leverage to Bitcoin, and we expect its performance to continue lagging," Markus Thielen, founder of 10x Research, told CoinDesk. He added that the exclusion had long been anticipated, so most of its impact was already reflected in the price. "We don't see a spillover effect into Bitcoin itself. Since Bitcoin peaked a year ago, treasury companies have had less and less influence on the market, and many investors realize these companies add no value beyond the Bitcoin they hold."
Thielen's view represents the camp that is optimistic the market has digested MSCI's decision. Many funds, he said, are already underweight MSTR—holding a smaller share than the index requires—so selling pressure could be lighter than headline estimates. However, independent Bitcoin analyst Derin Olenik sees the bigger risk in the institutional adoption narrative. He estimates the exclusion could trigger US$2.8 billion in selling, potentially surging to US$11 billion if other index providers follow. "This is a big blow to the 'institutional adoption' narrative that underpins the entire treasury model," he said.
Both Thielen and Olenik agree that Bitcoin treasury companies need to evolve. Thielen urges such companies to act like asset managers—optimizing their asset base through yield strategies and proving they can beat the market, not just financial engineering. Olenik is blunter, calling the exclusion "good riddance" and calling for "Treasury 2.0": companies that don't just hoard coins but build Bitcoin infrastructure, drive network adoption, and compound sats for shareholders through real operations. The question is whether Strategy and other treasury companies can transform before the mNAV premium truly falls below 1x and shuts off their funding tap.



