Burnham's First Test: Welfare Reform Sparks Internal Turmoil in the Labour Party
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Perdana Menteri Andy Burnham menghadapi ujian kepemimpinan dengan rencana pemotongan tunjangan disabilitas bagi usia muda yang diusulkan Alan Milburn.
- Berbeda dari pendahulunya, Burnham disebut lebih aman karena para pentolan pemberontak tahun lalu kini mendukung pemerintah.
- Partai Buruh diprediksi tetap dilanda gejolak, tetapi skalanya diperkirakan lebih kecil dan tidak sefatal krisis sebelumnya.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham is bracing for the most risky political test since he took office at Downing Street: reform of the welfare system that could trigger a rebellion within the Labour Party. The plan to cut benefits for young people is a litmus test of Burnham's leadership, as he has promised to rein in state spending without repeating his predecessor's mistakes.
Alan Milburn, a former minister from the New Labour era, has spent a year preparing a review on how to reduce the nearly one million young people who are not in employment, education, or training (NEET). In an interview with The Times, he confirmed he will recommend cutting benefits for some recipients of Personal Independence Payment (Pip) and the additional health element of Universal Credit in the 16-24 age group. This group accounts for about 11% of all Pip recipients.
Milburn's recommendations are not automatically a threat to Burnham. Unlike last year, when 120 Labour MPs nearly derailed the reform proposed by Keir Starmer, this time several key rebel figures are in fact on the government benches. Louise Haigh, now the most influential cabinet minister after Burnham, and Anneliese Midgeley as chair of the parliamentary party, are said to support the move. Meg Hillier, who led last year's rebellion, has even said she wants to give Milburn's proposals a "fair wind".
Milburn's approach is also different. He does not start with budget cuts, but with upfront investment to support unemployed young people, with a timeframe for net savings of about ten years. This is a gradual strategy, not a sharp shock. In addition, the cuts target only the under-25 group, unlike last year's reform which affected all age groups.
Several ministers who previously voiced concerns about the plans of Rachel Reeves and Liz Kendall now express support. One of them said that as long as there is adequate support for young peopleโin the form of job guarantees and trainingโMPs will be "fine" with benefit cuts. However, he stressed that those genuinely unable to work must not be harmed. Milburn is even considering additional payments for that group, as well as a living allowance for young disabled people who lose Pip.
Nevertheless, resistance remains. Rachael Maskell, the MP for York who rebelled last year, described stripping Pip from young people as "like using a sledgehammer to crack a nut". She worries that the benefit is in fact needed by disabled people to stay in work. Maskell also stressed that the government "should not just point the finger at young people" and needs to encourage employers to hire more young people. Simon Opher, the MP for Stroud who also rebelled, said Milburn had offered a "credible solution", but benefit cuts must be a "last resort". He warned that a quarter of young health benefit recipients are not NEET, so "the devil will be in the detail".
"I am not sure I can support the cuts. You cannot get young disabled people into work by taking away the money that actually helps them get a job," said Bell Ribeiro-Addy, MP for Clapham and Brixton Hill.
Similarly, Brian Leishman from the party's left wing said he could not support benefit cuts because "we are in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis". This stance shows that a rebellion is still possible if Burnham accepts Milburn's recommendations. However, its scale and political impact are expected not to be as great as the storm that shook the Starmer government.
For Indonesia, the dynamics within the Labour Party mirror how developed countries grapple with the dilemma between fiscal discipline and social protection. The UK faces budget pressure from a surge in welfare spending after the pandemic, while Indonesia is also expanding social security programs and targeting a reduction in youth unemployment. Policies that are too harsh can trigger public resistance, while delaying reform risks burdening state finances in the long term.
With Milburn set to release his official recommendations next week, the question now is: will Burnham be able to maintain the balance between fiscal demands and social justice, or will he face a rebellion larger than expected? It all depends on the details of the reform package and how quickly support for young people is delivered before benefits are withdrawn.



