UK Suppresses Climate Report but Promotes Its Author to Security Adviser
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Pemerintah Inggris tetap menolak mempublikasikan laporan intelijen yang memetakan risiko keamanan nasional akibat keruntuhan ekosistem global.
- Perdana Menteri Andy Burnham menunjuk Madeleine Alessandri, arsitek laporan tersebut, sebagai utusan khusus keamanan iklim di tengah kontroversi.
- Langkah ini memicu kritik karena dianggap tidak sejalan dengan serangkaian kebijakan energi yang masih berpihak pada bahan bakar fosil.

The UK government under Prime Minister Andy Burnham is still withholding a crucial document: a report outlining the national security threats posed by the collapse of global ecosystems. This stance has been maintained even after the central figure behind the report, Madeleine Alessandri, was given a new advisory position at Downing Street. The decision was announced by Burnham while speaking at the COP31 Climate Summit in Turkey on Thursday (12/11/2026), and immediately raised questions about the consistency between rhetoric and action.
Alessandri, former head of the Joint Intelligence Committee (JIC) which oversees MI5 and MI6, was appointed as climate security adviser. She is the figure who pushed for the drafting of the report that is now kept under tight wraps. The report itself was supposed to be launched at last year's COP, but was withheld by the previous government under Keir Starmer. The Guardian leaked its contents, and earlier this year a partially edited version circulated. Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband has even briefed several foreign governments on the report's findings, yet the original document remains unpublished.
In his speech, Burnham reaffirmed the UK's commitment to reaching net zero by 2050 and building a clean energy future. "The message I bring at my first COP as prime minister is that the UK remains determined to reach net zero by 2050 and to work with partners to build a clean energy future," he said. He also highlighted that the global consensus on climate science and climate action has collapsed, and that the UK will not stand idly by.
Burnham emphasized the importance of electrification as the path to energy security. "If we depend on energy we do not control, we depend on prices we cannot control. The shift to clean energy is the only route to energy security," he said. He also claimed that new electric cars are now cheaper than petrol cars, and that with the right tariffs, heat pumps are more economical than gas boilers.
However, behind that speech, several major decisions with climate impact were taken separately. Ministers are reportedly finalizing a weakening of rules requiring carmakers to increase the share of electric vehicle sales. Burnham has also given the green light to the Jackdaw gas field, cut heat pump funding, and is considering support for the Rosebank oil field. Meanwhile, Chancellor John Healey is known to prioritize economic growth even at the cost of locking the UK into expensive fossil fuels.
"His speech struck the right tone, but the offstage noises about big new oil fields and looser electric car rules almost drowned it out. Appointing the world's first climate security envoy is a welcome step, but approving Rosebank will only increase the climate threat to communities in the UK and around the world," said Ami McCarthy, head of politics at Greenpeace UK.
Criticism also came from within the government. Several senior officials argued there is no dedicated climate adviser working directly for Burnham at Downing Street, even though the issue matters to many voters. They worry that major decisions are being taken without considering their cumulative impact.
Nevertheless, Burnham received support from Fatih Birol, executive director of the International Energy Agency. In a meeting on the sidelines of COP31, the two discussed how cheaper renewables and economic electrification can lower the cost of living. "I can say that his mind and heart are fully behind the electrification of the UK energy system. I would vouch for that. We spoke very deeply," Birol said.
For Indonesia, this dynamic is an important mirror. As a country vulnerable to the impacts of climate change, Indonesia has a stake in watching whether developed nations like the UK are consistent between promises and policy. When a report mapping climate security risks is instead kept hidden, the signal sent to developing countries could weaken trust in global commitments. Indonesia's energy transition, which depends on international support, could also be affected.
Going forward, the public will wait to see whether Burnham will publish the report or leave it buried. If not, the promise of a "new era of UK leadership" on the climate stage will be mere rhetoric without substance. The question is simple: why is a report said to be so important being hidden from a public that has the right to know?



