UK Home Office Refusal Letter Names Wrong Country: Blind Nigerian Grandmother Told to Seek Treatment in India
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Seorang pensiunan Nigeria berusia 67 tahun yang buta dan telah tinggal di Inggris selama 26 tahun ditolak permohonan izin tinggal permanen karena dianggap bisa berobat ke India.
- Aturan permukiman baru yang diumumkan Menteri Dalam Negeri Shabana Mahmood memperpanjang masa tunggu bagi migran lanjut usia, sehingga banyak yang berisiko meninggal sebelum memenuhi syarat.
- Kasus ini memicu kritik keras dari organisasi hak migran yang menilai kebijakan tersebut kejam dan kontraproduktif, sementara Home Office berjanji menerbitkan surat perbaikan.

A 67-year-old Nigerian woman who has lived in the UK for 26 years faces a bitter reality: the British government has rejected her application for permanent residence and suggested she seek treatment in India—a country she has never visited. The woman, known as Comfort, was blinded by acute glaucoma that struck shortly after she arrived in the UK in 2000.
The case surfaced amid the rollout of new settlement rules announced by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood this week. The rules extend the waiting period for migrants seeking indefinite leave to remain (ILR). For Comfort, who had previously been scheduled to obtain ILR after 10 years of visa renewals, she may now have to wait up to two more decades—or until she is in her 80s.
Lawyers from Refugee and Migrant Justice (RMJ) had in fact filed for an expedited ILR on grounds of age and disability, invoking special provisions for exceptional cases. But the Home Office refused. The refusal letter stated that Comfort could return to Nigeria because services for the blind are available there. Ironically, the letter's closing paragraph instead said: “Your circumstances are not so severe or lacking in potential treatment in India as to warrant indefinite leave to remain.”
The policy has sparked widespread concern among migrant rights organizations. They consider the extension of the waiting period—which for some people rises to as much as sixfold—inhumane, especially for vulnerable elderly migrants. Nick Beales, campaign director at Migrant and Refugee Justice, said Comfort was in fact already eligible to stay and that there was no public interest requiring her to keep renewing her visa.
“Instead of viewing this vulnerable group as human beings, the government is obsessed with appearing tough. Shabana Mahmood's plan to double the settlement route will clearly make the problem worse, especially since the decision-maker cannot even tell India and Nigeria apart,” Beales said.
He also highlighted government data showing that people over 80 are still applying to enter the settlement route. According to Beales, they are unlikely to survive a 10-year waiting period, let alone 20 years. “The government must acknowledge that this ‘earned settlement’ model is cruel and counterproductive, and then scrap the plan,” he said.
The Home Office itself said it was taking corrective action by issuing a new letter for Comfort. A spokesperson for the department stressed that it does not comment on individual cases, but that all leave-to-remain applications are considered carefully in line with the rules and the evidence submitted.
Even so, Comfort's case is only the tip of the iceberg. Data compiled by RMJ reveals that many pensioners applying for settlement risk dying before meeting the new requirements. A 103-year-old Pakistani woman, for instance, will only be eligible at age 123. Meanwhile, for Comfort, she can only hope the Home Office shows compassion and grants her ILR now. “I don't know why the Home Office said I could go back to India. It is a country I have never visited and has nothing to do with me,” she said.
The case is a test of the British government's commitment to balancing strict immigration policy with humanitarian values. If the new rules are enforced without adequate exceptions, the wave of criticism from civil society is predicted to keep growing. Will the Home Office review a policy seen as discriminatory, or will it hold firm for the sake of political image?



