When Refugees Stop Being Whole Humans: A Critique of Heroic, Villain, and Victim Narratives
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Film dokumenter Seize the Summit menampilkan empat pengungsi yang mendaki Kilimanjaro, menantang stereotip kaku tentang pengungsi.
- Narasi media sering mereduksi pengungsi menjadi korban, penjahat, atau pahlawan, menghilangkan kompleksitas kemanusiaan mereka.
- Pentingnya mengembalikan pengungsi sebagai individu utuh agar integrasi sosial dan kebijakan suaka lebih manusiawi.

A film screening in London last week reignited debate about how the media and the public view refugees. The film, titled Seize the Summit, follows the journey of four refugees—Shaqayeq from Afghanistan, Adnan and Safa from Syria, and Tania from Ukraine—as they attempt to reach the summit of Kilimanjaro. Yet behind the story of the climb lies a more fundamental message: refugees are complex human beings, not merely a category.
The discussion after the screening, led by a Goldsmiths graduate named Hanya, highlighted that the film's aim is to popularize the idea of refugees as whole human beings. Hanya, who comes from Gaza, said that one thing refugees are often denied is a sense of humor. The remark drew laughter from the audience, but at the same time illustrated how stereotypes have diminished their humanity.
In mainstream coverage, refugees often appear in three guises: the desperate victim, the potential villain, or the hero who overcomes impossible odds. Yet, according to observers, heroic narratives usually come instead from the second generation of the diaspora telling stories about their parents. Meanwhile, refugees are discussed en masse only in terms of the host country's capacity and the permitted length of stay. Individual complexity—strength, trauma, the desire to build a new life, and the longing to return—is rarely exposed.
The film also highlights how war-induced disability drastically changes lives. Safa, a victim of severe burns, failed to reach the summit because of breathing difficulties. Adnan, who was shot by a sniper and lost bodily function from the chest down, also did not make it to the top. His journey is not about climbing a mountain but about learning to accept help after a decade of trying to be self-reliant. The moment he realizes he needs others in order to see the mountain is one of the most moving scenes.
Ronan Toal, a human rights lawyer who took part in the panel, noted that in Somali, the word for applying for asylum is “surrender.” This concept is often lost when refugees are not portrayed as whole human beings: how painful it is to hand one's fate over to the mercy of others. If refugees are not allowed to have personalities, it will be difficult for them to feel like a whole part of their new society.
Indonesian context: As a country that often serves as a transit point for asylum seekers, Indonesia faces a similar challenge in terms of refugee narratives. The media and the public tend to see them as a social problem or an economic burden, rather than as individuals with potential and vulnerabilities. In fact, a more humane approach can influence local policy and public acceptance.
The film does not embellish the experience of war but instead shows that the climbers often laugh. That laughter is not a heroic narrative but a reflection of ordinary humanity. By understanding refugees as whole human beings, asylum and social integration policies can be designed more empathetically and effectively. The question is, will the media and policymakers begin to abandon stereotypes and see them as whole persons?



