UK Softens EV Target, a Warning for Indonesia's Electric Vehicle Ambitions
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Pemerintah Inggris dikabarkan akan menurunkan target penjualan mobil nol emisi dari 80% pada 2030 menjadi sekitar 60%, memicu kritik keras dari kalangan pemerhati lingkungan.
- Kelonggaran aturan dan penundaan tenggat dinilai sebagai kemenangan lobi industri otomotif yang enggan berinvestasi dalam transisi kendaraan listrik.
- Bagi Indonesia, sikap mundur negara maju ini bisa memperlemah tekanan global terhadap produsen otomotif untuk mempercepat elektrifikasi, sekaligus mengancam daya saing ekspor.

The UK government is under heavy pressure after indications emerged that its zero-emission car sales target will be revised down from 80% in 2030 to around 60%. If actually implemented, this policy would deal a severe blow to efforts to decarbonize the transport sector and raise questions about the consistency of the country's climate commitment amid the COP31 climate summit.
Since the 2030 deadline was announced under the Conservative government, a series of concessions have been granted to carmakers. They were allowed to sell hybrid vehicles in place of pure electric vehicles, and given leeway to meet the target gradually with a promise to accelerate sales after 2030. Now, that flexibility is reportedly set to be extended to 2034, which critics call a systematic effort to avoid climate responsibility.
Energy and environmental policy experts assess that this maneuver is the product of strong industry lobbying. Automotive companies are said to be aggressively pressuring the government under the pretext of threats to jobs and national interest, when their real concern is the investment cost of overhauling production lines and developing new technology. "This is a form of legalized extortion," said an observer who declined to be named, describing the pressure felt by policymakers.
The comparison with Chinese manufacturers further highlights Europe's lag. BYD, the Chinese automotive giant, recently launched the Seagull, a tiny electric car with an affordable price and super-fast charging technology. Meanwhile, European manufacturers such as Volkswagen have only just introduced a cheap electric model but face production capacity constraints due to a lack of factory investment. "European manufacturers spent 2024 and 2025 convincing Brussels that the CO2 targets were unrealistic, yet now they are overwhelmed meeting demand," wrote the automotive site Autonext, as quoted.
Instead of accelerating the transition, the UK government is reportedly considering imposing tariffs on Chinese electric cars, following the European Union scheme. This step is seen as merely raising the price of environmentally friendly vehicles and worsening the cost-of-living crisis, without addressing the root cause of the domestic industry's lag.
"Car companies could have seen this change coming 130 years ago. Over the past 30 years, electric motor technology has developed rapidly and clearly represents the future. Now they complain they are not ready, and the only reasonable answer is: bear the risk yourselves," wrote The Guardian columnist George Monbiot in his opinion piece.
The hybrid policy as a middle ground is also seen as counterproductive. Hybrid cars still produce emissions nearly equivalent to pure petrol or diesel vehicles, are more expensive to operate than EVs, and are generally incompatible with fast chargers. Yet, because of government policy, the hybrid market share actually rose to 14% of new car sales last year. "The hybrid is a symbol of the government's indecision: faced with two technologies, two worlds, two futures, they chose both," Monbiot criticized.
The UK's failure to articulate a clear energy transition is also reflected in the absence of a massive public information campaign. Automotive companies' marketing budgets are still used to promote large, fuel-hungry vehicles instead of educating the public about the benefits of electric vehicles. In fact, the transition to EVs is not only about the environment, but also about energy resilience and long-term cost savings for consumers.
Indonesian Context
For Indonesia, the retreat of the UK and several other European countries is a worrying signal. Indonesia is aggressively building an electric vehicle ecosystem, from nickel downstreaming to fiscal incentives for electric car purchases. However, if developed countries that should be pioneers instead soften their targets, global pressure on automotive manufacturers to invest in clean technology could ease. As a result, electric vehicle prices in the domestic market could remain high because global production scale is not growing as fast as expected.
In addition, Indonesia, as an exporter of nickel and battery components, needs to be wary of the changing policy landscape in Europe. If the UK and the European Union slow the transition, demand for battery raw materials could weaken in the medium term, ultimately affecting the trade balance and investment targets in the downstreaming sector. On the other hand, Indonesia's large domestic market could be a buffer if the government consistently provides stable policy signals and does not get caught up in short-term tug-of-war between interests.
Going forward, the question is whether the UK government will let the automotive industry keep delaying the transition, or instead take firm steps to lead the change. For Indonesia, this moment should be a reminder that relying on other countries' commitments in the energy transition is a risk. It is time for the national electric vehicle policy to be designed on the assumption that major trading partners may not always move as fast as promised.



