COP31 on the Brink of Failure: Panama Says World 'Held Hostage by Oil Mafia', 30 Countries Form Fossil Treaty
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Menteri Lingkungan Panama Juan Carlos Navarro menuduh dunia terperangkap kepentingan industri minyak yang menghambat kesepakatan iklim di COP31.
- Sebanyak 30 negara sepakat membentuk traktat non-proliferasi bahan bakar fosil di luar proses PBB, sementara negosiasi resmi masih deadlock soal transisi energi dan pendanaan adaptasi.
- Dana adaptasi hanya terkumpul US$50 juta, anjlok dari US$135 juta tahun lalu, memicu kemarahan negara berkembang yang menuntut komitmen konkret negara kaya.

The UN climate conference COP31 entered its final 48 hours without a breakthrough. Panama's Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro delivered a sharp critique that summed up the frustration of developing countries: the world, he said, is being "held hostage by the oil mafia" and appears powerless to break free. The statement came on the sidelines of a press conference launching a new coalition aimed at a total phase-out of fossil fuels.
Navarro did not stop at rhetoric. He described the world's relationship with the extractive industry as a collective Stockholm syndrome—a blind love for the "kidnapper" that is somehow believed to be the rescuer. "They torture us supposedly for our own good, they destroy this planet supposedly to help us," he said, as quoted by The Guardian. The remark became one of the sharpest jabs to emerge from the COP31 negotiating table.
Outside the official negotiating rooms, 30 countries formally joined the Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative—a parallel agreement deliberately built outside the UNFCCC framework. The move marks a shift in tactics: instead of waiting for a consensus of 200 countries that often stalls, more ambitious nations are opting to form a "coalition of the willing" to speed up the energy transition. Colombia, which initiated the Santa Marta process last April, is continuing a similar initiative, with Tuvalu hosting the next meeting.
The thorniest issue is money. Mohamed Adow, Director of Power Shift Africa, accused rich countries of offering only "crumbs" for the adaptation fund. The figures in circulation are indeed lopsided: this year's commitments are only a third of last year's, even as developing countries' needs for coping with extreme weather keep swelling. "Hearing ministers praise the adaptation fund and then give almost nothing, you wonder how they think that fund can work," Adow said.
Similar disappointment came from Brandon Wu, Policy Director at ActionAid USA, who judged the "just transition" mechanism to be a major step back compared with previous COPs. He specifically accused the European Union of being the main obstacle in discussions on adaptation finance and protection for workers in high-carbon industries. The accusation adds to the list of frictions between developed and developing blocs that have colored the two weeks of negotiations.
"We are falling in love with our own kidnapper. They are so clever at convincing us that all of this is for our own good." — Juan Carlos Navarro, Panama's Environment Minister
Irene Vélez Torres, a former Colombian minister who initiated the Santa Marta talks, highlighted the 35% electrification target for 2035. She worries the figure does not explicitly require renewable power sources. "I am very afraid this target is not firm on green energy, because it could mean we end up locking in a new dependence on gas and coal," she said. The concern is relevant for developing countries that still rely on fossil-fuel plants to meet surging electricity demand.
Interestingly, Ethiopia—host of next year's COP32—has gone further by leading the "negative emissions" group, namely countries aiming to absorb more carbon than they release. Ethiopian Ambassador Samuel Addis Alemayehu stressed that such ambition requires financial support and technology transfer from rich countries. World Resources Institute President Ani Dasgupta stressed that cutting emissions alone is no longer enough: "We have to actively pull carbon out of the atmosphere."
For Indonesia, the dynamics of COP31 are more than a diplomatic spectacle. As a country with vast tropical forests and an energy transition commitment that still depends on coal-fired plants, Jakarta's position sits at a crossroads: supporting ambitious targets while demanding adequate adaptation funding. A failure by COP31 to agree on a clear funding mechanism could make it harder for Indonesia to finance its energy transition and peatland restoration programs that have so far been relied upon as carbon sinks.
A new draft is scheduled for release Thursday morning local time, and will test whether the Australian presidency can bridge the gap between developed and developing countries. If not, COP31 risks closing with a weak agreement—an outcome that activists say is already visible on the horizon. The question now: will developing countries choose the coalition path outside the UN, or stay at a negotiating table they feel no longer favors them?



